We headed to Cape Cod; the minivan filled with inflatables, towels, a packed cooler, and three excited boys. My husband was driving. We had been fielding the kids’ repeated question of “Are we there yet?” for the past half-hour. Our car slowed as we approached the bottleneck at the Sagamore Bridge.

The FM dial stayed tuned to 102, a classic rock station. Sting’s familiar melody played with the pulsing of alternate beats on the middle tom-tom and snare. The upright bass throbbed a double count. “Every breath you take,” a huge hit for The Police, won Best Song at the 1983 Grammys. Even 20 years later, the radio played it a lot.

Words sung from a shattered heart—breath, move, bond, step, vow, smile, claim. A strong desire of possession felt in the aftermath of separation. He wanted to follow his ex wherever she went. The lyrics undid me, as happened every time I heard them.

In the front passenger seat, I turned towards the side window and closed my eyes, unable to avoid the images. They ran like a filmstrip; frames crisp and in vivid color.

A different hot summer day. In the humid morgue, the protective gear felt suffocating. I wore an N-95 mask, face shield, plastic gown, booties, and a double layer of gloves. As the Chief Medical Examiner, I had a busy schedule with three cases that morning. All of them required full autopsy examinations. The first up was a woman I had met the night before, the night she was murdered.

“Are you ready, Dr. J?” my assistant asked as he unzipped the body bag.

I paused, contemplating the question and whether I would ever be ready for extreme brutality.

“Let’s begin,” I said as we took our places.

I thought back to the crime scene. Part of the responsibility of the medical examiner was to investigate the circumstances. The location of death, the surrounding environment, and witness statements provided context to whatever the autopsy would ultimately reveal. I observed this woman’s final moments charted in blood and chaos.

The body had not yet been moved; she lay where she took her final breath. Dried and liquid red gore outlined the dead woman as she sprawled on the floor. The original white of her uniform dyed crimson. Haphazard scarlet footprints patterned the ground. The six-inch long murder weapon positioned across the room like a horror movie prop.

Her ex-husband had been stalking her for weeks. On the day of her death, he phoned and threatened her. She had an order of protection, but the cops couldn’t help her. They told her that since the man wasn’t physically near her, they were powerless to react to verbal intimidation.

Her former spouse watched from the street, then went into the nursing home where she worked. He pushed past the receptionist, assistants, and patients. In a communal room, he grabbed her from behind. She was a big woman, but no match for his more muscular frame and adrenalin-fueled passion. Screaming, kicking, punching, she fought to free herself. Co-workers threw furniture at him as he repeatedly stabbed her with a butcher knife. One chair broke as it hit his back. An attendant tried to grasp the man’s pant legs. The attacker swung the blade in a wide arc preventing anyone from drawing near. A clerk dialed 9-1-1. The air filled with screams and sobs.

In the autopsy suite, the woman lay on the gurney, still bloody from the knife attack. Stabs and slices concentrated on her head, neck, and upper chest surrounded by cerise smears. The loss of blood paled her naturally brown skin. She wore a look of surprise. Even though I knew this was a postmortem change, it haunted me. I closed her eyelids.

I counted 103 sharp wounds on her body. Superficial cuts lined her hands and forearms where she tried to cover her head. The yellow underpinning of the fatty tissue of her scalp glistened from slashes down to the skull. Black hair matted in the wounds. Dozens of bruises colored her arms and legs from the struggle with her killer.

A trail of open lesions began on her face in front of the right ear and extended to the shoulder. The murderer thrust the blade through skin in a staccato fashion. Individual punctures might have been survivable. Except for one, right below the middle of the collarbone; the underlying artery severed. If someone had been able to get close enough to apply pressure, maybe she wouldn’t have lost a fatal amount of blood. A futile thought.

In the morgue, the radio played in the background while the technician and I worked. Sometimes music eased the tension.

“And now, an oldie but a goodie, and one of the top 100 songs of the twentieth century,” said the DJ. In the midst of my examination, I listened to Sting’s signature piece.

And now, years later, in a traffic jam on the eastern shore of Massachusetts, it sounded again sending echoes of the horror of that day.

The boys grew quiet. My husband reached over and took my hand. His right thumb rubbed my left one. He did not know the specifics of why I was crying; it was enough to know that I was. Then dropping my hand, he turned the radio off. A moment of silence for a victim from long ago.

Her ex-lover was watching her, and then I was.

I realize that I always will be. Watching her.

Other people’s lives are spread out in black and white across my bed, ready for editing. Pen in hand, I select the closest story. My oldest daughter leans in to read over my shoulder. At fourteen, she’s developing into a mini version of me—same shoulders; same pear-shaped curves; her hair beginning to curl, like mine did at her age. So similar to me and also my opposite in personality: her stage-loving, extroversion doesn’t come from my genes. We share this, though: a love of stories.

In my job, I often find myself editing other people’s lives. It feels like a privilege. People offer up their stories and trust me with their secrets. They reveal themselves in their rawest form: before they cut away parts they’re too scared to share, before they edit themselves or trim away scenes. They let me share their exhaustion, their joy, their struggle to be the mother, father, daughter, friend, lover they want to be. Whole or broken, I carry their stories in my mind like precious artifacts, especially the mothers’ ones.

One mother, a writer not much younger than me, gives birth to her second child. She holds her stillborn baby boy, wrapped in hospital blankets and kisses his cold cheek. Through her eyes, I watch with hope as her stomach grows again for the third time. She gives birth—afraid, praying. We gaze together at the tiny baby in her arms, finally arrived, pink and full of life.

“Can I read that one?” My daughter points to a page covered in notes, red arrows, editing marks she has learnt and understands. Today I decided to edit on paper rather than online like I usually do. My co-editor has sent me the first twenty stories for a contest we’re running and I feel the need to hold them. There’s something about the sensation of paper in my hands as I read that makes it easier to enter the story world. It also means my homeschooled daughter can be involved.

“Sure.” I hand her a moving story of a mother who lost someone they loved. My daughter is old enough to appreciate loss. She’s experienced her own losses. Ones I wish I could’ve sheltered her from. In a single year, we lived through my divorce, the loss of a loved one to drug addiction, and the death of two friends—all piled one after the other. I wish I could take a red pen to those scenes. Cut them out with long diagonal lines: “Remove this whole section.” But you can’t rewrite life. So I carry her story and mine; a braided essay of threads entwined. Woven together as mothers’ and daughters’ stories are.

I’ve been a writer and editor for over a decade now, helping others shape their stories. Both my girls love to read, but my oldest is fascinated by my work. She’s a published writer herself and I’ve learnt not to underestimate her editing skills. “Is this a good one?” she asks. “I like the first sentence.”

“It’s really well written,” I say, pausing in my work to watch her. My talkative teen is silent; her whole body quiet, focused on the page in her hands. Her face relaxes and I recognize the feeling—it’s the same one I experience the moment a powerful story touches your soul. “Oh! It is,” she whispers.

I hesitate at the door with a writer in her 60s: a sister, a mother, a widow. She’s afraid of the news on the other side. My heart beats with hers as she wonders who she’s lost this time.

Parents wish we could shelter our kids from some stories, edit the parts of their lives where they were hurt, where life was hard. There are scenes from my own life I’d love to remove too. I’d erase the days I sat with my knees curled to my chest and wept over a man I knew wasn’t good for me. The years I wasted because I was too anxious to live fully; too perfectionist to take any action in case it was the wrong one—I’d cut those with one hit of the delete key.

A young divorcee pours her fears onto the page. We sit side-by-side on the couch, my hand over hers, covering the empty space where her wedding ring used to be. I feel her relief; her marriage was toxic. I nod with her as she writes out her doubts, fourth paragraph in. Could it have been different? Could she have done something, said something, been someone different? And what about the kids? I don’t have an answer. I wonder the same thing.

Editing other people’s real stories, I realize all of us come with twisted plot lines. We can plan a romantic-comedy-life all we like and still end up in a tragedy. We don’t always get to choose the events but what we do with them matters. Our narratives shape us and we shape them in the retelling. The raw material can be crafted into precious gems. We get to give our stories meaning and make them something more: Something we want to carry with us.

The saddest stories are made powerful. The painful parts of our lives are made beautiful. My divorce, our friends’ deaths, and the drug-addicted family member wasn’t a year of meaningless tragedy. Through it my daughters and I found joy and closeness in small moments: crepes with strawberries on a Sunday, a warm fireplace to read The Magician’s Nephew in front of, endless episodes of Full House while we snuggled in bed. We created a new peaceful home. A new chapter in our story.

“What’s this one about?” my daughter asks, pointing to another story on the pile between us. “That’s another sad story,” I say, “but it’s beautifully written.”

She grabs it and snuggles in beside me. “I like those ones.”

I read over my daughter’s shoulder. “I like those ones too,” I say.